just between you and me
The son of the sista of my heart (which I suppose makes him the nephew of my heart) sent a contribution via the button for guest posts, even though he doesn't have a blog.
He did ask that I post my comments and opinions regarding surveillance and the telecoms.
I have so many conflicting thoughts on this subject. I hate like hell to take sides on controversial issues, especially on my blog, because it tends to inspire more conflict between us than it does resolution to situations.
The best-case scenario is an agreement to disagree; a worse-case scenario is a bunch of people explaining at the top of their caps-locks why I couldn't be more wrong, misinformed, and ignorant; the worst-case scenario is the ending of a friendship/mutual respect — a loss that could easily have been avoided if I'd just kept my wrong, misinformed, and ignorant viewpoints to myself.
Even that best-case scenario makes me unhappy. But it was so little for him to ask.
In a nutshell, my instinct is to say that I, personally, don't have anything to hide. If the government wants to waste its time listening to me talk smack about my former employers and whine about the fact that my friends are slurping diet cherry limeades when I would have to drive ninety miles to get to the nearest Sonic, they're more in need of a life than I am.
On the other hand, I'm one of the ones paying for that. I give the government my hard-earned money (which is no longer flowing in like it was, oh, this time last week), and they eavesdrop on me. I can think of about five million things I'd rather have them do with that money.
On the other hand, the biggest problem I have with surveillance as it currently stands is that, although the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) used to protect our rights to not be spied upon, that got sort of overridden by the Protect America Act. By dancing around the original language of FISA, a proposed amendment including immunity for the telecoms could leave them more safe from prosecution for invasion of privacy than I think we are from being invaded, period.
In a rather annoying nutshell, it is completely legal for them to tap a citizen's communication media to "keep us safe" (and from what? my pathetic attempts to console E over the death of her husband? oh, yeah, that's the act of a terrorist, innit), and they may do so without holding any sort of judicial review. Just, if they think you're a threat, they can move forward and get their listen on.
How are they making such a call, without a judicial review? Even "trusting a gut instinct" is exercising some sort of judgment ... don't they want to get a second opinion? Wouldn't they want one, if they were the citizens under scrutiny?
How silly of me, to assume personal integrity was going to play a part in this fiasco.
But on the other hand, who's going to pay for the judicial review?
And on the other hand, is it really keeping us safe?
And on the other hand, how can we expect anyone to be honest with us about whether or not our phone sex has evolved into a gang rape, when I personally am not a hundred percent sure anyone's even actually reporting all of the news, and have not been since Peter Jennings started not feeling so well?
How many hands is that? One, two, three, four, five, six.
Ultimately, it comes down to two big problems.
- I've only got two hands.
- I'm not qualified to have even one opinion about this at all, and the ones I've already voiced are almost certainly wrong, misinformed, and ignorant.
In short (I know; too late), the whole freaking government, a bunch of people who still have jobs and make more than I ever made before I became a budgetary constraint, can't make up their minds what the best, safest course is in regard to finding out who's got it in for us, and I'm just one person who takes a millenium to pick out a greeting card. Don't be mad that I can't come up with the right answer, is what I'm saying.
Two hands.
For your own edification, here is the left hand:
http://www.pfaw.org/pfaw/general/default.aspx?oid=24935
and here is the right hand:
http://www.gop.com/blog/Read.aspx?GUID=4798169f-61a2-4a2d-ba8a-829eef93f06e
Please feel free to make your own decision, and I wish you luck of it. My brain hurts from trying to figure it out.
And my own left hand doesn't know what my right hand is doing, except that both hands are feeling mighty arthritic, this cold, rainy-arsed day.
I'm still "selling" guest posts. Most of them are not this wrong, misinformed, and ignorant, I assure you.
